Skip to content
Search
Incinerator building with a tall white stack and a small steam plume under a blue sky with power lines in front.
Politics

Council panel votes 6-0 to cut Reworld incinerators from Philadelphia trash deal

By: The Philadelphia DigestDate:

Photo: SamHolt6 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

A Philadelphia City Council committee voted 6-0 to reject Mayor Parker's seven-year deal to keep sending the city's trash to Reworld incinerators, among them the nation's largest, which sits in Chester.

Members of the Committee on the Environment rewrote the administration's waste disposal ordinance, Council said in a release. They struck Reworld. Landfill contracts with WM and Republic went on to the full Council.

About 30 percent of Philadelphia's trash now goes to incinerators, and the administration had asked Council to keep it flowing there for seven more years under a contract that, because it runs longer than a year, needed Council's approval.

"We have been clear for over a year that we won't tolerate the toxic status quo," said Councilmember Jamie Gauthier, who chairs the committee.

Her office dug through DEP and EPA data. It counted nearly 400 violations and nearly $1 million in fines at Reworld Delaware Valley over two decades.

Councilmember Dr. Nina Ahmad, who chairs the Public Health and Human Services Committee, said she asked Reworld for health data in 2025 and never got it. "I cannot, in good conscience, vote in favor of the new contract without evidence-based data," she said.

Eric Bazis testified under subpoena. He spent nearly 30 years at Reworld Delaware Valley, and he told the committee that workers there were never instructed to swap out aging monitors: "We were not told to replace them, just to make sure they showed numbers that looked right."

Parker's own administration found in its analysis that incinerators are safe only when continuous, high-performance controls are in place. Reworld Delaware Valley doesn't meet that standard, Council said.

Delaware County adopted a plan last year to move all of its trash away from incinerators. Starting in 2027, at least half the waste handled by the Delaware County Solid Waste Authority will stay out of incinerators after a vote by the authority, Chester officials told Council.

Delaware County Council commissioned a life-cycle assessment that Philadelphia's Council called the only study focused on the region's incinerators, landfills and waste. It found burning worse. Burning trash and then burying the ash does 23 times more harm to health and the environment than burying the trash unburned, Council said.

Chester Health Commissioner Dr. Kristin Motley said the plant is a major source of pollution even by its own reports. Philadelphia breathes that air too, said Dr. Walter Tsou, the city's former health commissioner: "our airport is under 9 miles away from the Reworld incinerator."

Ending incineration ranks among the best ways to cut respiratory illness, the American Lung Association told Council.

Mike Ewall, who heads Energy Justice Network, sided with landfills. "It's clear that landfills in our state impact far fewer people and are the lesser evil we must choose as we work to reduce our waste," he said.

Philadelphia shut its last incinerator inside city limits decades ago, citing the harm to the neighborhoods around it.